Sports Medley: Why
Taylor Will Not Be MVP 7 Aug 17
by Tony Medley
On October 21, 1975 I
was watching the sixth game of the World Series between Cincinnati and
Boston. At the completion of the top of the eighth inning with
Cincinnati leading by three runs, 6 to 3, Cincinnati had only six outs
to get before they would be world champions.
At this point, before
the Red Sox came to bat in the bottom of the eighth, my friend, George
Mekjian, called me on the phone and asked me what I thought was going to
happen. I barely paused when I said, “Bernie Carbo is going to hit a
pinch-hit three run home run to tie the game.” George laughed at me and
hung up.
About a half-hour
later, after Carbo had come up to pinch-hit for pitcher Roger Moret with
two outs and two runners on base, and had, as I predicted, blasted a
three run pinch hit home run over the centerfield fence to tie the game,
George called back and inquired, “How in the world did you know that?”
The game remained
tied until the bottom of the 12th inning when catcher Carlton
Fisk hit a home run to win the game for Boston and send the series into
a 7th game. Fisk’s home run has passed into lore as one of the most
famous hits in baseball history. Carbo’s home run has been virtually
forgotten. But Carbo’s home run was far more historic than Fisk’s. If
Carbo does not hit his home run, Cincinnati wins the game and the World
Series in nine innings. If Fisk does not hit his home run, the game
continues. Yet Fisk got all the glory.
I raise this, not to
suggest anything about my prescience (astounding as it was) but because
of my contention that, to date, Chris Taylor has been the Dodgers most
valuable player, despite the fact that most of the glory has gone to
rookie Cody Bellinger, shortstop Corey Seager, and veteran Justin Turner
who leads the league in hitting.
I outlined my reasons
a few weeks ago, and they were validated in a game last week. The
Dodgers were trailing the Giants 4-3 in the bottom of the seventh
inning. Taylor came to bat with two outs and the tying run on second
base. After getting two quick strikes on him, he worked the count to 3-2
and then lined a double to left field scoring the tying run, thereby keeping
the inning alive for Corey Seager to follow with a two run home run to
give the Dodgers their final victory margin of 6-4.
The next day in the
newspaper Seager got all the glory (to be fair, Seager deserved a lot of
credit since he hit 2 home runs in the game, just not all of it). His
picture was on the front page of the sports section and the game writer
spent the entire article gushing about Seager. In fact, Taylor’s name
was mentioned only once, after the jump to page 3, where it was stated
in passing that “Chris Taylor doubled off Kontos to tie the score.”
Taylor is constantly
getting the overlooked and virtually forgotten hit with two outs that
keeps the inning alive and allows the Dodgers to win. Like Carbo’s home
run in the ’75 World Series 6th game, Taylor got the hit that
kept the Dodgers in the game without which they would have lost while
without Seager’s home run, the game would simply have continued in a
tie. Taylor is the Dodgers MVP so far this year, but he will never get
credit for it because the people who write about and publicize what
happens in each Dodgers game don’t understand the essence of the game
well enough to tell the real story. And the writers like the one
referenced here are the ones who vote for the MVP.
The Miami Dolphins
made what may prove to be their best play of the year this week. They
got a huge break when their underperforming starting quarterback, Ryan
Tannehill, was injured in practice and is probably out for the year.
They took advantage of this to sign former Chicago Bears quarterback Jay
Cutler as Tannehill’s replacement. Cutler never got the protection or
had the receivers he needed in Chicago. Miami has a better offensive
line and better receivers. This could be the breakout year Cutler fans
have been expecting throughout his career and put Miami in contention
for the playoffs.
|