Sports Medley: The
NBA’s list of its Top Players; Really? 29 Feb 16
If you want to see
witlessness in action, look at the NBA’s list of its 100 top players.
Here are the top 10:
-
Michael Jordan
- Kareem
Abdul Jabbar
- LeBron
James
- Magic
Johnson
- Wilt
Chamberlain
- Larry
Bird
- Bill
Russell
- Tim
Duncan
-
Shaquille O’Neal
- Hakeem
Olajuwon
Words don’t fail me
but any list of “the greatest” NBA players that doesn’t start with Bill
Russell is an ignorant, uninformed sham. It’s akin to a list of “the
greatest” baseball players that doesn’t lead off with Babe Ruth.
For a league that
prizes “rings” above all else, Russell was the most dominant sports
figure in the history of the United States. In two years of college
basketball he won two NCAA Championships, losing only one game in the
process (to UCLA). In 13 years of playing in the NBA he won 11 “rings.”
And one of his two losses was in 1958 when he was injured and didn’t
play in the 4th and 5th games of the Championship
series against the St. Louis Hawks, both won by St. Louis, and was
hobbling in the final 6th game (when Bob Pettit, another
great player disrespected by this list, scored 50 points. The NBA lists
Pettit at #34, just above Jason Kidd; which is damning with faint
praise).
Russell won with
Coach Red Auerbach. He won without Coach Red Auerbach. His team almost
completely changed personnel three times in the 13 years and he just
kept winning. Here are the starting lineups in his first championship
year and his last championship year:
1957
1969
Tommy Heinsohn
Bailey Howell
Jim Luscotoff
Tom Sanders
Bill
Russell Bill Russell
Bob Cousy
John Havlicek
Bill
Sharman Larry Siegfried
Coach: Red Auerbach
Coach: Bill Russell
To contrast, Michael
Jordan never won a “ring” without Phil Jackson and Scotty Pippen. How
many “rings” has James won? Two in 12 years, both with the same team and
the same players and coach. In 20 years of play, Jabbar won only 6
“rings,” and only one without Magic Johnson.
Ranking Wilt above
Russell could only be explained by youngsters who never saw them play
and make their decisions on statistics. Russell consistently outplayed
Wilt or at least held him even (Wilt was 7-1, 4 inches taller than
Russell at 6-9) when they met. And, for the record, in his entire career
Wilt only won two “rings,” and never won an NCAA title.
“Rings” aside,
statistics don’t begin to tell the story of Russell. If you never saw
him play you cannot conceive of how his presence on the court dominated
the entire game. He was a basketball savant, towering above everyone
else.
If you speak with
people who played or followed the game in the ‘50s and ‘60s, you will
find very few (I would say none) who would ever pick Wilt or any of the
other six players listed here above Russell. It takes a lot of chutzpah
and a lot of ignorance to publish a list like this.
|