Sports Medley: Time
to End All Star Games 20 February 2017
by Tony Medley
When Chicago Tribune
Sports Editor Arch Ward sponsored the first All Star Game in Chicago in
1933, the game had a legitimate purpose of determining who would win a
game between the best players in the National League and he best players
in the American League. Here are the comments of two publications at
that time:
The ensuing game promises to be an
even greater attraction than the World Series, as it provides, for the
first time, a test of the best talent in each major league. —
Sporting News
It offers them (the fans) the fairest
test of strength between the two great leagues, and at the same time
assembles, at one contest, the best individual players on the diamond.
Such a contest is a headliner of headliners, the realization of a
baseball fanatic’s dream. —
F.C. Lane, writer and editor of Baseball Magazine
In that game, the starting lineups
played pretty much the entire game. Pepper Martin, Frankie Frisch, Chuck
Klein, Chick Hafey, Bill Terry, and Wally Berger all had 4 at bats for
the NL. Ben Chapman, Charlie Gehringer, Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Jimmy
Dykes, Joe Cronin and Rick Ferrell all had four at bats for the AL. The
game lasted 2:07. Only 25 players saw action excluding pitchers.
The game stayed a
legitimate game for several decades before it descended into the
travesty it is today, where starters only play few innings and every
player can expect to see some action during the course of a game that in
2016 lasted 3:07 and saw 41 players play excluding pitchers.
But baseball’s All
Star game, sham that it is, still stands in stark contrast to the
debacles put on by the NFL and the NBA.
We can actually
pretty much forget about the NFL’s Pro Bowl because everyone knows
nobody plays to win and it’s not even as competitive as a flag football
game. Football, played seriously, is an extremely dangerous sport and
nobody in his right mind is going to put his body on the line for a
meaningless game that isn’t even entertaining.
That leads us to the
NBA’s All Star Game. This is a game that could be seriously played and
could have some meaning. But the fiasco that the league foisted on the
public last Sunday was an insult to the game of basketball. A score of
192-182? To call it absurd would be damning with faint praise. Nobody
made any pretense of playing defense or of having any care about winning
or losing. It was just a boring, idiotic display of shooting and dunking
without any opposition. Neither of these farcical affairs has the
remotest connection to sport or competition.
I know a lot of people who love sports, but I don’t know one who watches
the Pro Bowl or the NBA All Star Game. It’s time to deep six these
disgraceful exhibitions, and it’s time to put the baseball All Star game
back to what it was and should be, a game between the best of the AL and
the best of the NL to see who wins, and get rid of the rules that every
team must be represented and everyone on the roster gets to make an
appearance in the game. The way it is now doesn’t even come close to
satisfying the expectations of Arch Ward, The Sporting News, and
Baseball Digest.
|