Sports Medley: All
Time Dodgers teams 3 April 2017
by Tony Medley
In honor of the
opening of the baseball season, here are my all-time Dodgers teams.
Since there are two iterations of the Dodgers, there will be three
teams, one limited to Brooklyn, one limited to Los Angeles, and an
overall team.
Brooklyn:
Catcher: Roy
Campanella
First Base: Gil
Hodges
Second Base: Billy
Herman
Third Base: Jackie
Robinson
Shortstop: Pee Wee
Reese
Left Field: Zack
Wheat
Center Field: Duke
Snider
Right Field: Pete
Reiser/Carl Furillo
Pitchers: Don
Newcombe, Carl Erskine, Dazzy Vance, Preacher Roe.
Manager: Leo Durocher
General Manager:
Branch Rickey
This team looks a lot
like the 1953 lineup. Many people think that was one of the greatest
teams ever organized even though they lost a six game World Series to
the Yankees. Although Robinson played more games at second base than any
other position (regular from 1948-52; 1949 MVP), he also played first
base, third base, and the outfield. After Jim Gilliam became the regular
second baseman in 1953, Robinson played more games at third base than
any other position through the end of his career in 1956. He is the
second baseman on my all-time team (ahead of Rogers Hornsby). As to
Reiser, he was en route to being one of the best players of all time
until he ran into the center field fence in Sportsman Park in St. Louis
in the summer of 1942 suffering a fractured skull and he was never the
same as the man who burned the NL alive in 1941 leading the league with
a .343 batting average at age 22. He was hitting .380 when he ran into
the concrete wall in late July of 1942, with 19 hits in his last 21 at
bats. Durocher said he’s the only player who might have been better than
Willie Mays. So I split right field between him and Furillo who was a
good hitter (1953 batting title at .344) with a rifle arm.
Los Angeles:
Catcher: Mike Piazza
First Base: Steve
Garvey
Second Base: Davey
Lopes
Shortstop: Maury
Wills
Third Base: Adrian
Beltre
Left Field: Tommy
Davis
Center Field: Willie
Davis
Right Field: Kirk
Gibson
Pitchers: Sandy
Koufax, Don Drysdale, Fernando, Orel Hershiser, Clayton Kershaw.
Manager: Walter
Alston
General Manager: Al
Campanis
Clearly, Brooklyn has
it over L.A. except for pitching. After the Dodgers fired Al Campanis,
they were run by baseball imbeciles who let people like Piazza and
Beltre get away in the prime of their careers, not to mention Pedro
Martinez who wasn’t with them long enough to qualify to be one of their
top pitchers. Beltre became a star in his last year with the Dodgers
(batting .334), and then they let him get away to become the best third
baseman in baseball and a Gold Glove winner; so he edges out Ron Cey.
Gibson wasn’t with the team even as long as Beltre (1988-90), but his
pinch hit, crippled World Series home run in 1988 is just a skosh behind
Bobby Thomson’s 1951 “Home Run Heard ‘Round the World” as the greatest
moment in baseball history, which qualifies him in my mind for the
all-time team. It was close between Jim Gilliam and Lopes for second
base, but I pick Lopes due to his stolen base record.
Combined
Brooklyn/L.A.:
Catcher: Roy
Campanella, Brooklyn
First Base: Steve
Garvey, L.A.
Second Base: Jackie
Robinson, Brooklyn
Third Base: Adrian
Beltre, L. A.
Shortstop: Maury
Wills L. A.
Left Field: Zack
Wheat, Brooklyn
Center Field: Duke
Snider, Brooklyn
Right Field: Pete
Reiser/Carl Furillo, Brooklyn
Pitchers: Sandy
Koufax, L. A., Don Newcombe and Dazzy Vance, Brooklyn, Don Drysdale,
Fernando, Orel Hershiser, and Clayton Kershaw, all L. A.
Manager: Leo
Durocher, Brooklyn
General Manager:
Branch Rickey, Brooklyn
Both Garvey and
Hodges were Gold Glove fielders and good hitters but Garvey was a better
hitter. Even though Reese was the “Captain,” Wills changed the game
unlike anyone since Babe Ruth to return the stolen base to the game,
sparked the team to 4 NL titles and 3 World Series Championships, and
should be in the Hall of Fame. While Piazza was one of the purest right
handed hitters I’ve ever seen, Campanella, a 3-time MVP, was also
formidable at the plate and far out-paced Piazza defensively.
|