NFL's Officious Officials
by Tony Medley
These old time
NFL referees are simply ruining the game. In the Miami-Indianapolis game
a phantom holding call late in the fourth quarter cost Miami a very good
chance to win the game when a long punt return was run back to midfield
but a ref called holding that wasn't even plausible. In fact reruns
showed that the holdee was actually the guy who should have been called,
if anyone.
Then in the
Giants-Steelers game, a ref just called pass interference on an
absolutely perfect defensive play by Keenan Lewis. He barely touched the
guy and his touching had absolutely nothing to do with the fact that he
knocked the pass down. This led to a touchdown, having given the Giants
great field position.
These refs are
apparently under the delusion that it's their obligation to throw a flag
and that that's what people come out to see, yellow flags fluttering in
the air almost every time there's a good play. So many great runs are
called back by ridiculous holding calls or blocks in the back and so
many terrific defensive plays are nullified by pass interference called
that they ruin the game with these phantom calls. The sad thing is that
nothing can be done about it because the NFL obstinately defends all
calls, no matter how ludicrous.
I don't remember
any of these phantom calls during the strike. The replacement guys erred
on the side of no penalty. The "experienced" guys call a penalty
whenever they possibly can. As I said before, bring back the replacement
refs, who generally let them play and only called penalties that
actually were penalties. They might have missed a few, but I say it's a
better game when a few penalties are missed than when phantom penalties
are called.
What's really
amazing is when they blow obvious penalties that should be called. With
about five minutes to go in the second quarter of the Giants–Steelers
game, Ben Roethlisberger
fumbled. Giants Michael Boley picked it up and ran it in for a touchdown. However en route
to the goal line his
teammate, Jason Pierre–Paul, clearly blocked Pittsburgh Heath Miller
in the back. Miller was between Boley and the goal line and had a clear
angle on him. Pierre-Paul's illegal block allowed Boley to score. There
was nothing ambiguous about it. It was a blatant penalty that had to be
called. In fact it was such a stupid action by Pierre-Paul, it was an
outrage that he wasn't penalized.
So what was the
result? No flag was thrown on Pierre-Paul's illegal block in
the back, even though it occurred openly in the middle of the field
right in front of
a referee.
So the upshot is
that these referees call phantom penalties that nullify great plays,
ignore blatant penalties that result in long gains or touchdowns, and
often don't even get it right when they can review it on instant replay.
A terrific game
is being ruined before our very eyes by incompetent, self-aggrandizing
officials, who define the word officious.
November 4,
2012 |