Dodgers 22 recap
by Tony Medley
Nobody can say I didn’t
give a warning about the Dodgers being knocked out of the playoffs
despite their record-setting 111 victories in 2022. There’s an old adage
that “Managers don’t win ballgames, players do.” But that adage is not
true in the converse because managers DO lose ballgames and Saturday
night was one prime example.
I have never hidden my
disdain for the Dodgers’ Roberts’ constant hamartia when he deals with
pitching. It used to be infuriating when a manager would pull a pitcher
because the shortstop made an error. But Roberts pulls pitchers after
they have struck out the last batter. There is neither rhyme nor reason
to his decisions.
Last night he did it
again. He had a guy on the mound, Anderson, who was in total control but
Roberts pulled him after five innings of 2 hit, 6 strikeouts shutout
pitching. Interviewed on TV at the time, Roberts said he was
“comfortable” with his idiotic decision. The next guy struggled through
one inning, allowing two hits but no runs. Then Roberts put in a guy
named Kahnle to pitch the 7th with a
3-0 lead. He promptly walked the first batter on five pitches. IMHO when
a relief pitcher walks the first batter, he should be pulled
immediately, but he couldn’t be, due to the new rules that require a
relief pitcher to face a minimum of 3 batters (really it’s the Roberts
rule because twice he has used three different pitchers to pitch to
three batters in a 3 up 3 down sixth inning). So this turkey then
allowed two line drive hits and the Padres had one run in with runners
on second and third. Roberts then put in Almonte who allowed two hits,
but looked in control, striking out the probable MVP Mario Machado for
the second out. Then, after getting one strike on Cronenworth (there
were now two outs and the score was tied and Almonte looked in control),
Roberts popped out of the dugout and pulled Almonte, again for no
discernable reason and put in Vesia, who promptly allowed a line drive
single, driving in the winning runs and the Bums were dead.
If Roberts were a Japanese
General in WWII he would fall on his sword, but don’t look for him to
take responsibility because he only did what he has always done, shown
his total obliviousness about pitching.
While Roberts is the clear
goat of this experience, Trae Turner has to share some of the blame. He
was less than average in the field (being charitable) and his
performance at the plate showed that he is still a sucker for the
outside breaking ball in the dirt, and he generally failed in the
clutch. But we’ve probably seen the last of him as he will probably go
elsewhere as a free agent. That’s not a problem because I think that Lux
will be a star of the future at shortstop.
But, let’s face it, the
quality of baseball has shrunk considerably during my lifetime. Last
column I enumerated the weakness of the Dodgers’ starting lineup. But to
be specific, let’s compare this team with the Dodgers’ alltime two best
teams:
1953 1963
2022
c. Campanella Roseboro
Smith
1b. Hodges Skowron
Freeman
2b. Gilliam Tracewski
Lux/Muncy
3b. Robinson Gilliam
Turner
ss. Reese
Wills Turner
lf. varies
Davis varies but all weak
cf. Snider
Davis Bellinger
rf. Furillo
Howard Betts
Now here is how I would
play them, 1st team, second and third:
1st Team 2nd Team
3rd Team
c. Campanella 53 Roseboro
63 Smith 22
1b. Freeman 22 Hodges
53 Skowron 63
2b. Gilliam 53 Lux
22 Tracewski 63
3b. Robinson 53
Gilliam 63 Turner 22
ss. Wills 63
Reese 53 Turner 22
lf. T Davis 63
varied 53 varies 22
cf. Snider 53
W. Davis 63 Bellinger 22
rf. Furillo 53
Betts 22 Howard 63
As a note, in '53 Jackie
Robinson played 77 games in left field and 44 at third base (Billy Cox
played more games there), so I took the liberty of playing him there for
this team. So the ’53 team has 5 of the eight spots, the ’63 team has
two and the ’22 team has one. On the second team, the ’53 team has
three, the ’63 team has three and the ’22 team has two. On the third
team, the ’53 team has zero, the ’63 team has tnree and the ’22 team has
five.
Why is Betts only on the
second team? Furillo won the batting title in ’53 @ .344 with only 32
strikeouts, and had the best arm in baseball vs. Betts’ .269 with 104
strikeouts.
One might question why the
’53 team, that lost to the Yankees in the World Series in six games, is
listed ahead of the ’55 team that won a seven-game series against the
Yankees. The answer is twofold: first, the lineup in ’53 was better and,
second, ’55 was tainted because the Yankees’ best player, Mickey Mantle,
was injured and only had 10 at bats in the Series.
This analysis is just of
starting lineups and does not take pitching into consideration. But I
would rate the pitching staffs as follows:
-
1963
-
1953 (even though it
lacked Don Newcombe who was in the army)
-
2022 (but it might
have been much better if the staff could have pitched complete
games)
As a final nail in the
coffin of baseball’s quality today, only three batters in the NL batted
over .300 (and don’t tell me that’s because pitchers only throw 100
pitches, so batters face fresh pitchers in late innings; would a batter
rather face Sandy Koufax throwing his 110th pitch
or Joe Turkey fresh out of the bullpen?). I don’t know who led in
“launch angle” or the incomprehensible WAR. But who cares? Bring back
the good ol’ days where pitchers were men, five-inning pussycats were in
Ponca City, and managers knew something about pitchers and pitching !
|