Sports Medley: 2015 Super Bowl Recap
by Tony Medley
Pete Carroll meet Fred Merkle. Merkle was a rookie first baseman who
played for the New York Giants in 1908. In a key game with pennant
contender Chicago Cubs, the Giants had Merkle on first and Moose
McCormick on third with two out and Al Bridewell at bat, in a 1-1 tie in
the bottom of the ninth inning at the Polo Grounds. Bridewell hit a
single to center and McCormick crossed the plate with the apparent
winning run. Merkle, on first, thought the game was over so ran towards
the dugout to avoid the crowd that always flooded the field when a game
ended. Cubs’ second baseman Johnny Evers saw this and somehow got the
ball and stepped on second base, appealing to umpire Hank O’Day that
Merkle was forced out at second and the inning was over without the
Giants’ run counting, so the game was still tied. O’Day agreed with him.
With the field flooded with fans, the game was over. The Giants and Cubs
finished the season a few weeks later tied for the pennant, so the
replay of the tied game was essentially a playoff for the pennant and
the Cubs won, 4-2. The play has been memorialized ever since as
“Merkle’s Boner,” and Merkle was referred to as “Bonehead Merkle,” even
though what he did was standard operating procedure at the time. As a
postscript, the Cubs beat the Detroit Tigers in the World Series for
their last World Series Championship.
Carroll’s Seattle Seahawks had the Super Bowl in the bag. They had a
second and goal on the one yard line with approximately 30 seconds left
in the game, trailing 28 to 24, two timeouts remaining and the NFL’s
best rusher Marshawn Lynch ready for three tries to gain the 1 yard to
get into the end zone. Instead, Carroll calls for a short pass in the
middle of the field. It’s intercepted; the game is over; Seahawks lose!
This is much more of a
“boner” than what poor Fred Merkle did in 1908. And it should go down in
history as such, “Carroll’s Boner.” This isn’t Carroll’s first visit to
the bonehead school, though. In the 2006 Rose Bowl game against Texas,
USC had a fourth and two at midfield with 2:13 left in the game leading
by five, 38 to 33. USC’s star player was running back Reggie Bush, who
won the Heisman Trophy as 2005’s best football player. But when SC lined
up for their most important play of the season, Carroll called for the
ball to be given to SC’s other running back, LenDale White, who was
thrown for a loss. Texas took over and drove down for the game winning
touchdown. But the worst and most inexplicable part of it, Bush wasn’t
even in the game! He was standing on the sideline watching. One might be
able to understand Carroll calling for a play to fake a handoff to Bush,
who everyone would expect to carry the ball, and hand it to White as an
element of surprise. But with Bush not in the game, that ploy was out.
Who in their right mind would have the best offensive player in the game
on the bench for the biggest offensive play of the year? The answer to
that is the same guy who would throw a short pass into a stacked defense
instead of handing the ball off to the best runner in football to try to
make one yard, Bonehead Pete Carroll, a title he richly deserves off of
these two calls.
But this game was
actually lost late in the third quarter when Seattle was rolling and in
process of making it a rout. Seattle had scored 17 consecutive points
and had a third and three at midfield. Seattle quarterback Russell
Wilson threw a perfect sideline long pass that was right in Jermaine
Kearse’s two hands, but Kearse dropped it, resulting in a three and out
and a punt. When this occurred, I had a strong premonition that it was a
huge momentum swing and that New England was going to come back and win.
Voila!
Kearse is the same receiver who muffed two passes in the Green Bay game
that resulted in interceptions which contributed to Green Bay’s big lead
near the end of the game. If Kearse makes the catch, Seattle has a first
and 10 on the New England 20 near the end of the third quarter and a 10
point lead. It’s not unreasonable to think that they would go in to
score a touchdown, get a 17 point lead and put the game almost out of
reach, leading to an easy Seattle victory.
Kearse was almost a hero prior to Carroll’s bonehead call, however, by
making a spectacular, bobbling catch on the New England five yard line,
giving Seattle a first and goal with a little over a minute
remaining. After Kearse’s amazing catch, Lynch gained 4 yards to the one
on first down, and then Carroll called his mystifying pass play which
New England intercepted, basically ending the game with only 20 seconds
left. Talk about snatching defeat from the jaws of victory!
Kearse was also involved in the intercepted pass. Kearse’s job on the
play was to run an arguably illegal pick (the same play on which a
penalty was called that cost Notre Dame a winning touchdown over Florida
State earlier in the season) to screen defensive back rookie Malcolm
Butler from defending the intended receiver, Ricardo Lockette (who only
caught 11 passes all year long, adding to another mystery as to why he
would be the intended recipient of such an important pass), but Kearse
was held up at the line of scrimmage by Patriots’ cornerback Brandon
Browner, so the unscreened Butler had a clear run at the ball. To the
rookie’s credit, he recognized the play immediately and knew exactly
what he had to do. He is a potential star.
Brady played the spectacular game New England needed and was aided by
crippling injuries in the Seattle secondary. While Brady’s short passing
game is virtually indefensible, Seattle was known for not allowing many
yards after catches, but New England receivers constantly caught the
ball and ran for good yardage after the catch. Injuries to star
defensive backs Richard Sherman (who is rumored to require Tommy John
surgery), Kam Chancellor, Jeremy Lane (who made a key interception in
the first half and injured his arm bad enough to miss the rest of the
game), and Earl Thomas obviously had dire effects on the “Legion of
Boom” and the game.
I can’t end the article
without mentioning Seattle wide receiver Chris Matthews. Seattle’s
weakness all year has been the lack of a deep receiving threat. Matthews
was on the roster all year long, but played in only three games without
a reception, probably without a ball being thrown to him. Finally
getting a chance in the biggest game of the year, he was the star of the
game for Seattle, making several key, difficult receptions. How could
this player be on the Seattle roster without Carroll realizing his
talent? How could he not play in front of butterfingered Jermaine Kearse? |