Oppenheimer (5/10)
by Tony Medley
3 hours
R.
When I learned that
Christopher Nolan had written and directed a film about J. Robert
Oppenheimer (Cillian Murphy) that lasted three hours, John McEnroe’s
immortal words flooded my mind, “You cannot be serious!” Alas, it's
true. But, in order to present a sympathetic picture of this highly
controversial left-leaning scientist who led the team at Los Alamos in
developing the Atomic Bomb, Nolan has flooded the torturous first two
hours of the film with confusing flashbacks and flash forwards (some in
B&W), enough to make the viewer dizzy as well as perplexed (can’t modern
filmmakers make a linear film anymore?).
Nolan’s preconception
forces him to present President Truman (Gary Oldman) and Special Counsel
Roger Robb (Jason Clarke) as heavies. An example is when Robb confronts
Oppenheimer with indisputable evidence that he lied, Nolan manipulates
the scene so that the viewer sympathizes with Oppenheimer.
The left is gonna love this
film so it will probably be the subject of breathlessly adulatory
reviews and up for multitudes of awards, but I found it slow, confusing,
disjointed, and more predispositional than objective.
The film is sort of based on the McGuffin of
what did Einstein say to Oppenheimer in a meeting shown near the start
of the flim. In fact, Einstein and Oppenheimer were neighbors, but more
acquaintances than friends. What did Einstein say to Oppenheimer in the
film’s alleged meeting? We don’t know the validity of what Nolan writes
in the script but one of the few quotes of Einstein about Oppenheimer
extant is, “The
trouble with Oppenheimer is that he loves a woman who doesn’t love him —
the United States government.”
It picks up speed, however,
during the last hour when Oppenheimer is questioned by Robb during a
hearing challenging his security clearance.
Oppenheimer was a
complicated character. This film doesn’t uncomplicate anything (and
maybe that’s appropriate), but Nolan could have used a strong editor
with sharp scissors to make this shorter and more objective.
|