Tony’s 2009 Oscar Nominations & Winners
by Tony Medley
Some things don’t
seem to change. Once again the Oscars® have nominated films most normal
movie-goers would view as unworthy, which is why most people watch the
Oscars® to see what the women are wearing. The idea of a “best” is that
it be entertaining. But Oscar® eschews the importance of entertainment
in making its evaluations for its awards. Make an apolitical independent
film, like “Me and Orson Welles,” well, forget it, regardless of the
quality or entertainment value.
Even though Oscar®
continues to ignore comedy, you’ll see lots of recognition for comedies
and comedic actors in this list, even for movies that were not A+, like
“Year One” and the bomb “Couples Retreat.”
As I’ve said
before, an actor who takes mediocre material and makes something
memorable is more deserving of award consideration than someone working
with outstanding material. So
Peter Serafoniwicz
and David Cross are nominated for sparkling, funny, memorable
performances with undistinguished material.
And it’s mind-boggling that Oscar® failed to recognize performances like
the one given by Peter Sarsgaard in “An Education.”
Here’s the way I
would have nominated (since they are my nominations, I’m not limited to
five, but even though the Academy extended the list for Best Picture to
ten, I could only name nine that were deserving). My winner is indicated
by an asterisk:
Best
Original Screenplay
Bruce Joel Cohen
(Adventureland)
Scott Neustadter &
Michael H. Weber (500 Days of Summer)
*Julian Fellowes
(The Young Victoria)
Scott Cooper (Crazy
Heart)
Sheldon Turner &
Jason Reitman (Up in the air)
Quinton Tarantino
(Inglorious Basterds)
Best
Adapted Screenplay
Bruce Joel Rubin
(The Time Traveler’s Wife)
Nick
Hornby (An Education)
John Lee Hancock
(The Blind Side)
*Holly Gent Palmo
and Vince Palmo (Me and Orson Welles)
Jesse
Armstrong, Simon Blackwell, Armando Ianucci, Tony Roche (In the Loop)
Best
Supporting Actor
Billy Crudup
(Public Enemies)
Simon Pegg (Star
Trek)
Robert Patrick
(Alien Trespass)
Denis O’Hare (The
Proposal)
David Cross (Year
One)
Peter Serafoniwicz (Couples Retreat)
Jae
Head (The Blind Side)
*Christopher Waltz (Inglorious Basterds)
Best
Supporting Actress
Amy Adams (Julie &
Julia)
Olivia Williams (An
Education)
Catherine Keener
(The Soloist)
Vera Farmiga (Up in
the Air)
*Anna Kendrick (Up
in the Air)
Best
Actor
Joseph
Gordon-Levitt (500 Days of Summer)
Eric Bana (The Time
Traveler’s Wife)
Peter Sarsgaard (An
Education)
*Jeff Bridges
(Crazy Heart)
Christian McKay (Me
and Orson Welles)
Colin Firth (A
Single Man)
Best
Actress
Kristen Stewart (Adventureland)
Zooey Deschanel
(500 Days of Summer)
Rachel McAdams (The
Time Traveler’s Wife)
Carey Mulligan (An
Education)
Sandra Bullock (The
Blind Side)
*Emily Blunt (The
Young Victoria)
Hellen Mirren (The
Last Station)
Best
Director
Marc Webb (500 Days
of Summer)
Lone
Sherfig (An Education)
John
Lee Hancock (The Blind Side)
Jean-Marc Vallée
(The Young Victoria)
Scott Cooper (Crazy
Heart)
*Richard Linklater
(Me and Orson Welles)
James Cameron
(Avatar)
Jason Reitman (Up
in the Air)
Katherine Bigelow
(The Hurt Locker)
Armando
Iannucci (In the Loop)
Best Movie
(500) Days of
Summer
An Education
The Young Victoria
The Blind Side
Crazy Heart
*Me and Orson
Welles
Avatar
The Hurt Locker
In the Loop
|