Sports Medley:
Mattingly’s Perplexing Decisions 1 Jun 15
by Tony Medley
Mattingly is the
problem:
It’s not just that Dodgers’ manager Don Mattingly mishandles one of the
best starting pitching staffs in baseball. It goes much further than
that. This was exemplified, if not amplified, in Sunday’s game against
St. Louis, the best team in baseball.
One of the biggest
problems with the Dodgers offense this year has been that Mattingly
insists on having his two least effective hitters bat in the number one
and number two slots. Centerfielder Joc Peterson and shortstop Jimmy
Rollins have been ineffectual at the plate all year long. Peterson
either strikes out, walks, or hits a home run. He strikes out more than
a third of the time. He has more strikeouts (58) than hits (41),
projecting to 200 strikeouts for the year, which would be the major
league record for a rookie. Those facts are not what you want in the
leadoff hitter.
Jimmy Rollins, with a
batting average of .200 and an on-base percentage only slightly higher
is a rally killer deluxe. As bad, he can’t even bunt. Twice in the same
game he laid down sacrifice bunts so poor that the runner was thrown out
at third base each time on a tag, not a force play. These are the people
Mattingly wants batting at the top of the lineup, the players who get
the most at bats in each game. No wonder they can’t score runs. The
ideal batting order is to have people in the first two slots who can get
on base for the power hitters in spots 3 and 4 to drive in. For example,
the ’27 Yankees had Earle Combs, .356, leading off and Mark Koenig,
.285, batting second so they could be on base for Babe Ruth (60 home
runs, 164 RBI) and Lou Gehrig (47 home runs, 175 RBI) to drive in.
So on Saturday,
Mattingly finally inserted Justin Turner in the number two spot. Turner
responded by getting the Dodgers first hit of the game and scoring the
first run the Dodgers had scored in 42 innings on the road in a rare
road victory. Just when it looked as if Mattingly had finally reached
some accommodation with common sense by trading Juan Uribe and awarding
Turner the starting third base job, on Sunday Turner was inexplicably
benched again for .205 hitting Alberto Callespo, just dumped on the
Dodgers by the Braves.
That meant that almost
half the lineup (4/9) consisted of batters whose inability to get on
base is proven (Rollins, Pederson, Callespo, and the pitcher, although
Pederson does walk a lot when he’s not striking out). What does
Mattingly have against putting good hitters in the first two spots of
the batting order? What does he have against playing Justin Turner every
day? Why does he keep good hitters on the bench to play All-American
outs in their places? How does he expect to score runs when half of his
lineup can’t hit? Here’s my lineup v. Mattingly’s for the rubber game
against the best team in the league:
Medley
Mattingly
Turner ss
.303 Pederson cf .258
Ethier rf
.305 Callespo 3b .205
Kendrick 2b .290
Gonzalez 1b .324
Gonzalez 1b .324
Kendrick 2b .290
Grandal c
.284 Ethier rf .305
Guerrero 3b .290
Grandal c .284
Van Slyke lf
.264 Guerrero lf .290
Pederson cf .258
Rollins ss .202
My lineup has batters in
the first two spots who can get on base for the Nos. 3 & 4 hitters to
drive in. Mattingly leads off with two guys to whom first base is as
unfamiliar as Timbuktu (even though Pederson’s OBP isn’t bad due to his
walks; still since he's mostly a home run hitter, he should be batting
behind people who can get on base, which is why I have him 8th behind
good hitters).
Naturally, Callespo went
0 for 3, consistent with what Rollins does when he’s hitting second.
Anybody who would want both of these ineffective hitters in the game against a great team in an important series instead of Turner and Van Slyke is not qualified to be a major league manager.
As postscript, I grant
that Rollins is a better fielder than Turner, but Turner does a
workmanlike job and needs to be in the lineup every day, as does
Guerrero. Defense is not the Dodgers’ problem. Scoring runs is the
problem and the Dodgers have the talent to be one of the best offensive
teams in the league if only Mattingly would play the players who can
hit. And let’s not forget that the Dodgers traded the best leadoff
hitter in baseball, MLB’s leading hitter Dee Gordon, .377, who has the
most hits in baseball, 78, which is only one less than the total hits of
Rollins and Pederson combined.
Sportsnet’s Ineffective
Coverage:
Not only does Sportsnet LA refuse to show the strike zone box on every
pitch, it makes directorial decisions as goofy as Mattingly’s baseball
decisions. At the end of Sunday’s game Turner, a pinch hitter, was called out on strikes
for the last out of the game. Turner was livid at the last two strike
calls, and was engaged in an animated argument with the umpire as
Mattingly approached the pair. It was so important that even the LA
Times Sports section recognized it and put the argument in its headline.
Not to Sportsnet, though, which cut from the argument to show the
Cardinals walking off the field congratulating one another and the
announcers never again mentioned the argument. Mattingly’s management
decisions are agony enough to watch without also being subjected to
Sportsnet’s inept directing. The vast number of fans who are precluded
by the Dodgers from watching the Dodgers on TV should consider
themselves fortunate. |