Trial by Fire (7/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 127 minutes.
NR
This Is a Film With A Point Of
View. In 1991 the home owned by Cameron Todd Willingham (Jack O’Connell)
burned to the ground, killing his three little daughters. Willingham was
tried, convicted, and executed in 2004. Offered a plea deal to confess
in exchange for life imprisonment instead of the death penalty, he
refused because he said he was not going to confess to something he did
not do.
This film shows Willingham’s
trial and that he got a pitiful defense from his attorney, Horton
(Darren Pettie), who fails to cross examine witnesses and only presents
one witness in Willingham’s defense.
Elizabeth Gilbert (Laura Dern)
gets involved in the last hour of the film, disproving everything the
prosecution presented, and emphasizing Horton’s incompetence.
Directed by Robert Zwick from a
script by Geoffrey Fletcher, and based on a story by David Grann in
The New Yorker, this has been the subject of a 2011 documentary. The
film takes pains to show Willingham being framed by a corrupt criminal
justice system and undone by a lazy, incompetent attorney who apparently
prejudged his client as guilty.
The film also takes pains to
paint former Texas Governor Rick Parry as complicit in Willingham’s
execution by refusing to look at convincing evidence supporting his
innocence, his attorney’s malpractice, and unethical prosecutorial
conduct collected by Gilbert.
Gilbert provides pretty
conclusive evidence that witnesses changed their stories at trial from
what they originally told police. I don’t know if that’s true or not,
although it is true that the jailhouse informant recanted his testimony
that Willingham confessed to him, but denied that he had been promised
leniency in return for his false testimony, although independent
examinations have indicated that he did get such leniency.
This movie is very well done
with fine acting by everyone, especially O’Connell and Emily Meade as
Willingham’s feckless wife, Stacy. It’s up to the viewer how much to
believe.
|