Tolkien (7/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 110 minutes
PG.
This is reputedly the true story
of the young J. R. R. Tolkien, author of The Hobbit and Lord
of the Rings. He is often called the father of modern fantasy, even
though fantasy had been around long before he started writing.
The movie concentrates on
Tolkien’s relationship with his three fast friends from school, Robert
Gilson (Patrick Gibson as an adult and Albie Marner as a youth),
Geoffrey Smith (Anthony Boyle as an adult and Adam Bregman as a youth),
and Christopher Wiseman (Tom Glynn-Carney as an adult and Ty Tennant as
a youth). Together they formed the Tea Club and Barrovian Society named
for their mutual passion for sneakily sipping tea in the school library
or at nearby Barrow’s tea room.
Also told is the story of his
love affair with Edith Brant (Lily Collins), who became his wife, even
though his guardian, Father Francis Morgan (Sir Derek Jacobi), forbad
him from seeing her for three years.
More than a story of how he
became a great writer, this is a tale of fellowship, and it goes beyond
the bounds to add Hollywood touches to it. As an example, Tolkien is
shown barging into the WWI Battle of the Somme, in which it is estimated
that over a million men were killed, in order to find one of his
friends. Alas, this never happened. Although Tolkien was on the
continent in the army in WWI, he was sick most of the time. The scenes
of him roaming around the battlefield unarmed looking for his friend
while everyone else is armed and bombs are going off all around him
looks as contrived and silly as it is. It’s pretty amazing that director
Dome Karukoski allowed those scenes from the script by David Gleeson and
Stephen Beresford to actually be filmed. It mightily detracts from the
film’s verisimilitude.
There are lots of other scenes
that are of dubious authenticity, like one of him drunkenly awakening
the faculty by yelling in a square of the faculty quarters in the middle
of the night, and one of him taking Edith to a performance of Wagner and
not being allowed in due to the way he was dressed.
While the Tolkien family has not
seen the film, it issued a statement that it did not "approve of,
authorise or participate in the making of" the film.
The pace is ghastly slow, but
the acting is very good, it’s sentimental and sensitive, and an
interesting take on someone of whom most know very little.
|