Lore (5/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 108
minutes
Not for
children.
This is a
well-made but disturbing story of a 14 year-old girl (Saskia Rosendahl),
her sister, brother, and infant sibling, who are basically abandoned by
their German parents after V-E day in 1945 and have to walk hundreds of
miles across the devastated German countryside to find respite with her
grandmother in Hamburg.
While it sounds
like it could be a great adventure film, it is so stark and realistic
that there's no romance involved. Although it involves a long walk
across Germany, this isn't Saving Private Ryan, but a
cinéma-vérité look at what it was like to be German after the
annihilation of World War II.
Directed (and
co-written with Robin Mukherjee) by Cate Shortland, who was responsible
for the remarkably entertaining Somersault, which won multiple
awards in 2004 by the Australian film institute for best picture and
best director, among others, this is a dark, unforgiving story based on
the book The Dark Room by Rachel Seiffert. Co-starring Kai Malina
as the mysterious boy/man who joins Saskia in her treck, while another
story of a young woman in a difficult position, this is much blacker and
more unrewarding.
There are some
sexual scenes and short shots of nudity that make the film inappropriate
for children.
The performances
by Rosendahl and Malina are very good, but the story is so unremittingly
depressing that it's not the kind of film one would choose for an
evening's entertainment.
Shortland is a
talented director, and this film is well done, but I hope that her next
choice is more palatable. Movies are an entertainment. While this
presents a stark picture of what life was really like in Germany after
the end of fighting, it is not pleasant to watch.
In German.
|