Act of Valor
(4/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 101
minutes
OK for Children
The most
noteworthy aspect of this disappointing film is that all the action
scenes, which comprise more than 75% of the movie, were shot with 15
handheld DSLR Canon 5D cameras. Exacerbating the less than thin story
(which avoids apparently silly things like plot and planning), the
acting by real Navy Seals detracts from the film. The reason actors like
Bruce Willis (who played a Navy Seal in 2003's Tears of the Sun)
get the big bucks is that they can make one believe they are what they
portray.
This doesn't really do much for the
reputation of the Seals. The scenes are so poorly edited that the film
jumps from one action scene to another. It starts out with the Seals
trying to rescue a woman kidnapped in Central America. After that
snatch, it jumps to another attack. If you believe this film the Seals
just go from one problem to another with absolutely no planning. A good
war movie shows the planning of attacks. Filmmakers knew this Over 65
years ago in A Walk in the Sun (1945, originally Salerno
Beachhead) in which director Lewis Milestone had Dana
Andrews, Richard Conte, John Ireland and a bunch of other GIs walk to a
farmhouse in Italy where the Germans were ensconced. Dana spread out the
map and they all figured out what they were going to do and then they
executed it. This film was remade by Steven Spielberg as Saving
Private Ryan (1998).
Unlike A Walk in the Sun,
there is no planning here. The Seals are called in and they go for it.
They plan a little for the first attack, but when they go after a guy on
a ship, it seems as if it's every man for himself.
The filmmakers say they wanted the
story of the Seals told. But, why? This is a clandestine military group;
what's the point of publicity that seems inappropriate. But if you're
going to make a movie to cast plaudits on the Seals, why not make it
with established stars? Would Sands of Iwo Jima (1949) have been
better with a real marine instead of John Wayne? Let's face it, without
the Duke or someone of that stature, Sands of Iwo Jima wouldn't
have become the classic it is. This is nothing more than a low budget
action film with lots of noise and lots of bullets. The Seals deserve
better.
|