Thumbnails October 2008
by Tony Medley
The Duchess (10/10):
This atmospheric recreation of late 18th-Century upper crust
England, tells the spellbinding tale of Georgiana, the Duchess of
Devonshire (wonderfully played in another smashing performance by Keira
Knightley), whose life paralleled that of her descendent, Princess
Diana, and her cold, cruel spouse, Ralph Fiennes. Fiennes gives an
extraordinarily nuanced performance in capturing the Duke’s complexity,
raising the idea that maybe there is some feeling in the man, however
deep and well-hidden. Fortunately the first rate direction by Saul Dibb,
the gorgeous cinematography, set designs, and costumes, keep it from
dipping into a maudlin soap opera.
Lakeview Terrace (8/10):
Sparkling performances by Samuel L. Jackson and Patrick Wilson
create tension that slowly increases throughout this thriller about a
mixed-race couple that moves in next door to psychopathic LAPD policeman
Jackson.
Burn After Reading (7/10):
One thing that Joel and Ethan Coen know is how to make movies about
dumb people, “Fargo” (1996) being the prime example. This movie is
inundated with dumb people. Brad Pitt, George Clooney, John Malkovich,
Frances McDormand; you name them, they are dumb. But funny. All in all,
this is an enjoyable film with an A-List cast that lets you come out of
it no wiser, but probably in better spirits than when you entered.
The Women (7/10:
Instead of the clever, biting commentary with real meat by George Cukor,
Clare Booth Luce, and Anita Loos in the 1939 original, writer-director
Diane English’s intent is to “celebrate women” rather than skewering
them, which robs the story of its bite. Even so, despite a slow start
with unconvincing bonding among the friends, I enjoyed it. Eva Mendes
stands out as the airhead mistress and Annette Bening improves after a
weak start.
Nights in Rodanthe (7/10):
Novelist Nicholas Sparks’ sole goal in life seems to be to
manipulate tears. This is no exception. Although there are some really
silly “only in Hollywood” scenes, like the morning after a horrible
hurricane, Richard Gere hops in his car, parked outside, that looks as
if it has just been washed and polished. But this flimsy romance allows
women to look at Gere, who I guess is still a hunk, and men to look at
Diane Lane (whose beauty leaves me gasping for breath) for a couple of
hours, and what’s wrong with that?
Miracle at St. Anna (7/10):
Despite some clumsy dialogue at the beginning, some silly dialogue
during the initial war scene by screenwriter James McBride, and a crude
caricature of a tough-talking detective by John Turturro, after the
first half hour director Spike Lee picks this up into an interesting,
well-acted war/mystery/commentary on humanity, aided immeasurably by
Terrence Blanchard’s Oscar®-quality music and its 90-piece orchestra.
Appaloosa (5/10): Into
the middle of New Mexico’s wasteland in 1882, ride laconic Ed Harris and
Viggo Mortenson to rid a one street, one block town of bad guy rancher
Jeremy Irons, apparently by talking him to death. There’s no reason for
the town to exist, other than to make this movie. Despite the fact that
it’s comprised of at most 20 buildings, it’s got a newspaper and a train
station and a hotel! Even so, the acting of Harris, Morteneson, and
Irons almost makes it worthwhile.
Righteous Kill (2/10):
Burdened by director Jon Avnet’s annoying extreme close-ups, sitting
through this 111-minute debacle is akin to watching two amateur comics
giving bad impersonations of Robert De Niro and Al Pacino. Worse,
actually; the comics would at least be funny.
Ghost Town (1/10):
Ricky Gervais is such an unlikable
misanthrope that this clumsy attempt at a redemptive comedy is as
antipathetic as Gervais. Greg Kinnear, whose career once seemed to have
such a bright future, is particularly disappointing…again.
|