The Last Legion (0/10)
by Tony Medley
Whenever a studio doesn’t
allow critics to attend a screening before opening, that tells you that
the filmmakers and distributors (in this case Dino de Laurentiis and The
Weinstein Company, respectively) don’t have much faith that anybody who
sees it will have anything good to say about it.
And they were right! To say
that this is amateurish would be to elevate it to a level of
professionalism it does not achieve. When I see a film like this I am
unbelieving that so much work and money could go into something so
dreadful.
The story is that a young
Roman, Romulus (Thomas Sangster), is a direct descendant of Julius
Caesar, but some bad guys have taken over Rome in the sixth century and
are trying to kill him, after they killed his parents. He’s protected by
Aurelius (Colin Firth), who faces enormous odds in every fight. I mean,
he’s got the entire Roman Empire against him. Throw in the Emperor who
is now in Constantinople, and it’s basically the entire world. He’s got
about four guys who are supporting him. Four guys and a girl, that is.
Because the best fighter among them is Mira (Aishwarya Rai), who takes
on ten guys at a time and kills them all, emerging without so much as a
scratch. Rai is clearly no athlete because all her fights consist of her
pirouetting first this way, then that. Her opponents never catch on.
When she walks, she doesn’t have the walk of an athlete and her fight
scenes are burdened with innumerable cuts. First a pirouette, then a cut
to a slash, then a cut to a dead body.
Director Doug Lefler has
taken a woeful screenplay by Jez and Tom Butterworth, from a story
(hahahaha) by Carlo Carlei, Peter Rader, and Valerio Massimo Manfredi,
based “in part” on a novel by Manfredi, and made it worse. So many
writing credits indicate that nobody really wrote the screenplay. It
must have been put together piecemeal.
Movies are fiction. As
such, they often have to have scenes that ask the viewer to suspend
disbelief in order to further a plot, and that’s generally OK, if what
we are asked to belief is at least reasonable. But there are so many
idiocies in this movie that it quickly strains credulity to the breaking
point. Here are a few. Aurelius & Co. feel that they have to go to
“Brittania” to escape and preserve the Empire. They take off on horses
in their Italian garb (where it’s hot, you know?). In the next scene
they are crossing the Alps fully clad in snow garb. Where did they get
their clothes? What did they do with their horses?
Worse, they are climbing up
a peak that looks like Mount Everest, clearly the highest peak in sight.
In the background, however, is a valley about 10,000 feet below them
cutting through the mountains. Why did they decide to climb the highest
peak to get across the Alps when the valley was available?
Next, they are in a very
small boat, apparently crossing the Brittania Channel, which later
became known as the English Channel, much to the dismay of the French.
Then we see them landing at the White Cliffs of Dover and then riding
horses. Where did they get their horses? They didn’t have them crossing
the Alps and they didn’t have them in their boat and they didn’t know
anybody in “Britannia.”
Suddenly they are galloping
up to Hadrian’s Wall, which is very far to the north in England (that’s
where Britannia was, remember?). They had all of Brittania to visit; why
did they go there?
The cinematography (Marco
Pontecorvo) could have been some saving grace for this thing, because
the movie could have had some wonderful locations. Alas, the
cinematography is as bad as the rest of the film.
The thing that really
bothers me about this film is that Firth and Ben Kingsley (who plays
Abrosinus/Merlin) are pretty good actors. Kingsley won an Oscar®, for
heaven’s sake. What are they doing in something as terrible as this?
Don’t they read scripts? Are they that hard up for parts and money? They
didn’t produce, but they did get an “in collaboration with” credit. Take
it from me, it wasn’t worth it.
August 18, 2007 |