Show
Business: The Road to Broadway (10/10)
by Tony Medley
Whenever I watch backstage
stories about music, be it Broadway or recording an album or whatever,
I’m impressed by the number of people who work on these things and the
enthusiasm they all show. Thus it is that Dori Berinstein has made a
quintessential documentary telling the story of four musicals as they
prepare to open on Broadway, taking through their openings, up to The
Tony Awards at the end of the year and then close with an epilogue 6
months after The Tonys.
Berinstein shot more than 250
hours during the 2003-4 season, shooting on virtually every Main Stem
attraction, then pared down in the editing room to tell in 102 minutes
the backstage dramas of the four major musicals, from the low budget,
$3.5 million Avenue Q, to the $7.5 million Caroline, or
Change, the $10 million Taboo, and the $14 million
blockbuster, Wicked.
Along the way we learn many
charming things about Broadway, like The Gypsy Robe Ceremony, which
honors chorus members with the most credits on Broadway. The ceremony
for each of the four shows is shown to the background of “Tradition”
from Fiddler on the Roof. Players believe that the awarding of the Gypsy
Robe helps to bless the show.
Berinstein didn’t ignore the
major Broadway critics. She arranged for four of them to get together
four times during the year for lunch to discuss what was going on with
the shows. They met at Orso’s, Angus’s, Joe Allen’s and Sardi’s. Those
participating were Charles Isherwood of Variety, Michael Riedel of the
New York Post, Jacques le Sourd of Gannet News/The Journal News, and
Linda Winer of Newsday. This was a bad decision on Berinstein’s part,
for two reasons. The first is that this is basically an honest
documentary where Berinstein arguably had cameras in locations to film
people as they worked. Nothing was staged. To the contrary, the critics’
luncheons are obviously staged. As such, they jeopardize the film’s
verisimilitude, since, but for Berinstein these lunches, and their
contrived, self-serving conversations, would not have taken place.
Secondly, these people are so
full of themselves, so unlikable, that the film loses its pace when it
cuts to the meals. It did, however, capture the character of the
critics, and it is not a pleasant sight. They sit around talking about
“breaking boundaries” and “stasis is not something to show in a
musical.” Who ever uses the word “stasis” in ordinary talk? Never once
did I hear even one of them make any comment about whether or not the
show is entertaining. Not once did they comment on the tunes or the
lyrics. The dichotomy drawn between these people who express little but
disdain for what they are seeing, and the love and devotion of the
people who are putting on the shows is striking.
Other critics interviewed during
the film are Ben Brantley of The New York Times and John Lahr of The New
Yorker.
There are other fascinating
facts. Jeff Marx, the youthful Composer and Lyricist on Avenue Q.
revealed that he doesn’t read music. Since I can read music, and since
it seems a simple skill, it thrills and amazes me that people can live
their lives in music, like Paul McCartney, but can’t read it. Being able
to create great music without being able to read it, for me, defines
true genius.
The Avenue Q story is one of the
more compelling, created as it was by three young kids. Marx, an intern,
and Bobby Lopez, a temp, wrote the words and music and Jeff Whitty the
book. These were three guys out of nowhere.
The people are so dedicated and
in love with what what they do. The task is daunting; the decisions
immense. When considering changes, George C. Wolfe, Director of
Caroline, or Change, says, “To go from very good to brilliant is an
endless series of details…unbelievable details that lift it.”
It’s fascinating to watch the
creative people actually creating. There is a terrific scene in which
composer Jeanine Tesori is working on the epilogue for Caroline, or
Change. She is clearly frustrated in trying to get it to work,
explaining “This is the last big piece. It’s challenging. It’s important
and it’s not really there. It’s really hard to do. Because you can muck
it up very quickly if you rewrite the wrong thing because suddenly the
house of cards comes in a big pile at your feet.” At one point she just
bangs her head on the piano keyboard in frustration.
Says Raúl Esparza, an actor in
Taboo, “We’re all pouring all our energy and love into what we
do…because that’s the reason we do it. You do it for a lot of love, I
think.”
The way these people sublimate
their lives to their craft is impressive. Tonya Pinkins, the female lead
in Caroline, or Change was divorced and lost her children a year
before, but is bouncing back here. “There’s nothing you can do about
that,” she says. Unfortunately, the song they show her singing is less
than compelling.
Berinstein had cameras at the
locations where the people are watching the nominations for the Tonys.
It’s clear that they take these awards very seriously, indeed, and that
what we watch on the news when these nominations are announced, they are
watching, too, hanging on every word. There is a touching telephone
conversation between Lopez and his mother after he has learned he has
received a nomination.
The epilogue that brings the
story up to date as of 6 months after the Tony Awards is highlighted by
its music, mainly the Rogers & Hammerstein song from South Pacific,
Cockeyed Optimist, in a unique arrangement by Jeanine Tesori
performed by the Popstar Kids, and the Harry Warren/Al Dubin song for
Gold Diggers of 1935, Lullaby of Broadway with another unique
arrangement by Jan Follson and Tesori and performed by Idina Mentel, the
star of Wicked with vocals by various people.
If you love Broadway, you’ll
love this movie.
|