Where’s my Roy Cohn? (1/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 97 minutes.
PG-13
This is yet another film masquerading as a
"documentary" by a leftwing Democrat activist, this one named Matt
Tyrnauer. In fact the bias is communicated in the production
notes that read, “Roy Cohn’s best known exploits include: secretly and
unethically communicating with the judge to send Julius and Ethel
Rosenberg to the electric chair; collaborating with Sen. Joseph
McCarthy’s anti-Communist witch hunt; spearheading J Edgar Hoover and
McCarthy’s crusade to hound homosexuals out of government;
choreographing the New York State primary to split the vote and place
Ronald Reagan in the Oval Office; spreading damaging stories about
Geraldine Ferraro in 1984, scuttling her historic bid for the vice
presidency; abusing the law to keep many of America’s murderous
mafioso’s out of jail; and looting the bank accounts of his legal
clients.”
Wow! But just because someone says something is
evil does not make it so. Let’s take a few of these allegations. First,
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg did transmit nuclear secrets to Russia as
primary actors in facilitating communist Russia getting the atomic bomb.
If anybody deserved the death penalty for treason, they did.
Second, Sen. McCarthy’s work was only a “witch
hunt” to communists because there were communists in the State
Department. Alger Hiss, who was ardently defended by people like
Trynauer (who was wasn't born yet) was an active spy for the communists,
which was confirmed when the records of the Soviet regime were finally
seen after the fall of communism in Russia.
Cohn was the attorney for the Mafiosos, and it was
his job to defend them to the best of his ability. John Adams defended
the British soldiers accused in the Boston Massacre. What’s the
difference?
Tyrnauer interviews a long list of people,
including Ken Auletta, Liz Smith, Jason Epstein, Anne Roiphe, Marie
Brenner, Martin London, Robert Cohen, and others, all of whom are
Democrat donors. It’s hardly balanced by an interview with Roger Stone.
But throughout you get the idea that Tyrnauer’s
main point is not to paint Roy Cohn in a bad light (which, let’s face
it, is not difficult to do), it’s to tie him in to Donald Trump (who
apparently asked the titular question at one point)! Ah, Hollywood.
While
this is interesting, it is so terribly biased and clumsy (saying cruel
things like his mother was the ugliest woman in New York) it should be
taught in film school as an epitome of artless advocacy which has no
place in a proper documentary. Cohn was a difficult guy with a lot to
criticize (that’s an understatement). But even he deserves a more
even-handed treatment than this one that obviously went into the project
with its mind made up and its eye on the target in Washington.
|