The Young Karl Marx
Le Jeune Karl Marx (2/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 118 minutes
This was actually a
pretty good idea, making a biopic about Karl Marx, but not the old man
Karl Marx with a long beard who looked like Herman Melville (all those
19th century guys with their long beards look alike). No,
this is about an energetic twentysomething Karl Marx (August Diehl) of
whom the world has not yet heard, covering the years 1843–50. We also
meet his partner, a youthful Friedrich Engels (Stefan Konarski).
Director and cowriter
(with Pascal Bonitzer) Raoul (I Am Not Your Negro) Peck created
this tale using the actual correspondence among the people involved
including voluminous letters between Marx and Engels themselves. It
should have been a fascinating story but what Peck has produced is the
opposite, extraordinarily boring.
And that’s amazing
because Engels’ father was a rich industrialist and Marx was a
revolutionary thinker whose ideas did have a huge effect on the world.
To make the story of the struggle of Marx and Engels as uninvolving as
this film is mind-boggling. It failed the watch test dramatically. I
have no quarrel with the facts presented; it's the presentation itself
that misses the mark. It fails to convey all the tension that was
obviously there; at least I didn't feel it and neither did my assistant
who accompanied me to the screening.
As I was watching the
film, one thing that stood out is that both of the women involved with
Marx and Engels, Jenny von Westphalen-Marx and Mary Burns, are played by
beautiful actresses, Vicky Krieps and Hannah Steele, respectively. I was
thinking, yeah, sure, these women were probably frumpy 19th
century women. But at the end there are photographs of all the
principals, and the real Jenny and Mary indeed appeared in the
pictures, at least, to be of comparable beauty as the women who
portrayed them. In fact, the best part of the movie is the few moments
when we see what Marx, Engels, and all the other historical figures
really looked like when they were young.
The movie reminded me
of last year’s Dunkirk, an opportunity squandered, a failure to
capture the essence of what actually happened. In addition to that, it’s
yet another movie that’s filmed so darkly that it would have been better
in black and white. Why do some of today’s filmmakers eschew color and
light?
If this doesn’t put
you to sleep, nothing will.
|