Stan & Ollie (5/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 97 minutes
PG
Is it fair to downgrade a movie
because it isn’t what you expected and desired? I was disappointed
sitting through this because I was expecting a celebration of Hollywood
in the ‘20s and ‘30s through the story of Laurel & Hardy.
‘Twas not to be. Directed by
John S. Baird from a script by Jeff Pope, this is actually the story of
a little known tour of England by the boys in 1953 as reported by AJ
Marriot in his book “Laurel & Hardy: The British Tours.”
So even though they made over
107 films between 1927 and 1950 (32 silent shorts, 40 sound shorts, 23
features, and 12 cameos), this occurs after that, and that’s
unfortunate.
Because I have always been a
fan, I was dubious about watching two actors try to impersonate Laurel &
Hardy, but I have to admit that Steve Coogan and John C. Reilly are as
close to the real thing as anybody could ever get. The acting is nothing
short of superb. The few skits that are shown are well done, as is the
final dance.
But this is an end of life
story, the curtain-closing act, a downer. While it is interesting and
touches your heart, it was a terrific disappointment to me because of
what I had anticipated. I think it is poor judgment for the filmmakers
to make an entire film devoted to Laurel & Hardy for generations that
don’t really know them and to instead concentrate on end of life and
relationship issues instead of telling the story of how they met, how
they came to be a team and reach the enormous success and acclaim that
was theirs.
That’s why I’m warning you what
to expect. It’s a shame that Coogan and Reilly contributed their
enormous talents to a film that doesn’t really do justice to their
brilliance and talent.
If this were a story of some run
of the mill comedy team that worked together for a long time but weren’t
the huge success that Laurel & Hardy were, a film like this would be
appropriate. But until a biopic that tells the story of the amazing
success they were and how that happened, a film like this is untimely
and does their legacy no good.
Stay for the closing credits and
watch the real Stan & Ollie do a dance together on a western set.
|