Annihilation (5/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 115 minutes.
R
The first of a
proposed trilogy, this is an inscrutable sci-fi excursion that is filled
with tension and outstanding special effects and production design
without making a bit of sense. From director Alex Garland, who created
the outstanding Ex Machina (2015), some of the scenes intended to
terrify are so grotesque they could pass as homages to “Alien,” and come
close to crossing the line to satire.
Based on a novel
“Southern Reach Trilogy” by Jeff VanderMeer, the idea is that there is
an area (“Area X”), called The Shimmer that has been somehow
contaminated by an alien crash. It’s been blocked off, but several
expeditions have ventured forth to try to discover the “strange and
destructive forces emanating from it.” All of the expeditions have been
conducted by men, so the new one is conducted by women. One of them,
Natalie Portman, has a husband, Oscar Isaac (who co-starred with Alicia
Vikander in Ex Machina), who is the only survivor of any of the
expeditions, and he’s in really bad shape. So Natalie wants to go in to
discover what the heck is going on in there and she’s joined by a bunch
of women, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Gina Rodriguez, Tessa Thompson, and Tuva
Novotny.
Although Isaac is mentioned as a co-star, he’s just a token,
seen at the beginning and the end, and that’s it. He couldn’t have been
on the set for much more than a few days.
The problems of this
film for me are many, not the least of which is that the ending raises
more questions than it answers (none). My question coming out of the
film was, “What was that all about?” Why make a film that raises a
mystery of what’s going on and then give an unfathomable ending that
leaves the viewer nowhere but asking, “Huh?”? In the final analysis, this ending renders the
movie as little more than pretentious nonsense.
Despite the amazing
effects, it’s shot so darkly that what could have been stunningly
beautiful, isn’t. Then there are the characters. Maybe someone could
find Portman sympathetic, but the rest of them don’t establish any
feeling of empathy whatsoever.
This is like going to
a whodunit and when the movie ends not having a clue whodunit. If this
is the future of sci-fi, include me out.
|