Woman in Gold (9/10)
by Tony Medley
Runtime 110 minutes.
If I had to pick the
best actor in the movie business today I wouldn’t have to think twice.
Helen Mirren would win, hands down.
Here she plays Maria
Altmann, who was born in Vienna in 1916. This was nine years after Gustav Klimt had painted a gorgeous masterpiece in gold of Maria’s mother’s
Years later, after
Hitler’s Anschluss made Austria part of the Third Reich, Jews were
rounded up and sent to concentration camps and their businesses and
residences confiscated. Included in this confiscation was the Klimt
masterpiece and lots of other works of art that Maria’s parents had
collected in their opulent Viennese apartment.
This movie, directed by
Simon Curtis from a script by Alexi K. Campbell, introduces Maria living in
the United States in 1998. She hires Randy Schoenburg (Ryan Reynolds),
grandson of world famous composer Arnold Schoenberg, and a family
friend, to challenge the Austrian government’s claims to the Klimt
paintings. Thus begins an ordeal that has Maria and young Randy fighting
not only the Austrian government, but the American government as well.
This is a brilliant
movie telling the story with many flashbacks to Vienna in 1938 (young
Maria is well played by Tatiana Maslany, who truly looks like a young
Helen Mirren) that includes enticing cinematography of the Austrian
locations and some nasty business with the Nazis.
In addition to the fine
performances by Mirren, Reynolds, and Maslany, there are good supporting
performances by Daniel Brühl as Hubertus Czerin, a helpful Austrian
investigative journalist who became the prime mover in the case, and
Katie Holmes in a small but effective role as Randy’s wife, Pam.
The movie portrays Maria
as the owner of a small shop without a lot of money. I don’t know how well off the real Maria
was, but her brother-in-law was Bernhard Altmann, a world famous
clothier. In real life, Maria's husband, Frederick, was imprisoned in Dachau by the Nazis and held for ransom until Bernhard, safely in
France, transferred his lucrative textile mill to the Nazis. It was
after Frederick was released that he and Maria made their harrowing
escape. After she arrived in Los Angeles Bernhard sent her a cashmere
sweater with the note, “see what you can do with this.” This was,
apparently, the first cashmere sweater in the United States. She sold it
to Kerr’s in Beverly Hills. It was so popular that she started a
successful clothing business importing cashmere sweaters under the
Altmann name. One of her customers was Spencer Tracy’s mother. None of
this is mentioned in the movie, which pictures her merely as the
proprietor of her own small clothing store.
The scene in the U.S.
Supreme Court has Maria sitting next to Randy like in a trial court.
When I was in the Supreme Court clients were not seated at a table with
their attorneys. But maybe they had to film it this way to get Mirren in
For Los Angelenos paying
attention some of the segues for
the Los Angeles locations will be a little jarring. Just as an example,
there is a scene of Randy driving through downtown Los Angeles to a job
interview, but then there’s a stock shot of the building in which the
interview takes place and it is located in Century City 8-10 miles west
of downtown. Didn’t they have a stock shot of a building in downtown Los Angeles where they show Randy
But this is a movie and probably nobody else will notice the dichotomy.
My minor criticisms are
trivial. I was, frankly, enthralled throughout. My audience of critics
(which included director Curtis who arrived unobtrusively and sat in the
back row unnoticed until my friend, Sheila Roberts, another critic,
recognized him as we left the small screening room on Rodeo Drive in
Beverly Hills) applauded, which is unusual.