Last Chance Harvey (7/10)
by Tony Medley
Run Time 92 Minutes.
There are two scenes that
set this up and one that lets it down.
“John and Mary” (1969) was
Dustin Hoffman’s third starring role, after “The Graduate” (1967) and
“Midnight Cowboy” (1969). In it, he (John) hits on Mary (Mia Farrow) in
a singles bar, making a fool out of himself in front of Mary’s friends.
But Mary finds something sympathetic and a relationship is formed. But
it’s painful for John before Mary takes pity on him.
One of the most memorable
scenes in “Kramer vs. Kramer” (1979) showed Dustin (Mr. Kramer) sitting
in his attorney’s office during a Christmas party. He was angry and
upset and everyone else was in revelry. The scene I remember vividly is
Dustin sitting outside his lawyer’s office door, waiting for him, while
everyone else is partying it up. He is as alone as alone can be in the
midst of a crowd. Dustin does this alone-in-a-crowd business
Here, Harvey Schine
(Hoffman) is at his daughter’s pre-marital party and he’s so alone and
uncomfortable, surrounding by yuletide gaiety, that his loneliness is
palpable. He and his ex-wife have been separated for years and Harvey’s
daughter is going to be given away by her stepfather, Brian (James
Brolin). He is clearly the outsider. He’s as uncomfortable and alone at
the wedding party as John and Kramer were.
In the related scene, Kate
Walker (Emma Thompson, who gives her usual superb performance; in fact,
she carries the movie) is being fixed up with a younger man. She is
uncomfortable with him. Her friends have to leave suddenly, leaving her
alone with him. But shortly some of his friends arrive and join them.
Kate is as alone amidst laughter and fun as John and Kramer and Harvey.
The third scene that lets
the movie down occurs after a rather contentious first meeting and after
the two setup scenes outlined above. Both Harvey and Kate show up at the
same bar. Harvey sees and recognizes her and makes his approach. This is
where Dustin loses me. The dialogue is pretty good, but Hoffman’s
delivery misses the mark. He’s smiling and winking and trying to be coy
and cute like Hugh Grant, but it is dismally unbelievable. You can
almost hear the director telling him how to act through a megaphone. I
was squirming as Harvey was continuing to try to make a connection with
Kate despite her repeated rejections.
In “John and Mary,” John is
supposed to be inept. The point is that he is as bad at hustling as any
man’s worst nightmare, but Mary is sweet and finds his clumsiness
attractive. Here, Harvey is intended to be a suave and cool cat,
persevering despite Kate’s continuous rejections.
After that, though, this is
a sweet, if incredible, love story between an elderly man (Dustin is 71
as of this writing) and a middle-aged woman (Emma is 49). If you haven’t
already seen this story many times, you don’t go to the movies. Regis
and Kelly could have this film as one of their spin the wheel questions,
showing a scene and asking the audience what happens next. I would bet
that 95% of them will get the answer. It’s so derivative that it even
copies from the denouement from “An Affair to Remember” (1957).
In addition to Hoffman’s
bathetic hustling of Kate, there is a scene later on that is completely
out of touch with reality. Kate convinces Harvey that he has to attend
the reception so he, in turn, convinces her to go with him and offers to
buy her a dress. Here’s the setup; the party has apparently already
started, but first they go to a store to get her dress. Clearly time is
of the essence here. But that doesn’t bother them as she tries on dress
after dress. It’s not that they are all pretty dresses and she can’t
decide. No, the first four are so outlandish that the idea that she
would seriously even consider one as a possibility is beyond
comprehension, a monument to bad taste, a fault which Kate clearly does
not possess. Apparently these scenes of these horrible dresses are
inserted for what director (who also wrote) Joel Hopkins must have
thought comic relief. Not. It’s merely stupid because it’s
incomprehensible that she would try on all these dresses when they were
rushing to get to a party that had already started.
That’s just one example of
some of the old-fashioned tricks that Hopkins throws into the mix. I
don’t have the space to list the others. It is unrealistic diversions
like this that keep a film from being completely enjoyable.
Even so, while lots of men
will probably rue the day, I enjoyed it. But, then, I am nothing if not
a patient movie aficionado (if I were Hoffman I’d be smiling and
December 23, 2008